Insights Markets & Macro

A Rare Capitulation Signal From the Market

A breadth and momentum capitulation indicator hit -4.33, a reading seen only 13 other times since 1929. What happened after.

April 9, 2025 · 2 min read

Key points:

  • A breadth and momentum indicator plunged to one of the lowest levels in history, suggesting capitulation.
  • Similar oversold conditions saw the S&P 500 rally over the following six months in all but one case.

One capitulation indicator suggests a stock market rally

Several years ago, an anonymous source on the social media platform X, known as @MrBlonde_macro, shared a compelling capitulation indicator that caught the attention of market participants.

I recreated the indicator using a slightly different dataset while preserving its core logic. The model blends market breadth and price momentum indicators (see chart for components) to pinpoint capitulation or deeply oversold conditions.

On Monday, the indicator fell to -4.33, a reading that has only occurred 13 other times since 1929. Similar extremes have triggered explosive one-day rallies, translating to a staggering 2,763% annualized return for the S&P 500.

A capitulation indicator built from market breadth and momentum
Daily readings since 1928. On Apr 7, 2025 the indicator fell to −4.33, one of its lowest readings.
S&P 500 annualized return by indicator level, since 1928
When the indicator isAnnualized returnShare of days
Above −4.2510.8%100%
Below −4.252763.4%0.3%
Capitulation indicator
−8−6−4−2024619401960198020002020−4.25
−8−6−4−202461950197520002025−4.25
The indicator is a two-year rolling z-score of five inputs: the share of S&P 500 sub-industry groups more than 5%, 20% and 40% below their 252-day highs, and the S&P 500's rolling 63-day and 126-day returns. Concept courtesy of @MrBlonde_macro. Source: SentimenTrader, using S&P and CRSP data.

Similar oversold conditions produced a stock market rally

Whenever the capitulation indicator plunged below -4.25, the S&P 500 tended to rally over the next year. The most favorable window occurred at the six-month mark, which rose 92% of the time and displayed significance relative to random returns.

However, the world's most benchmarked index registered a loss in 8 out of 13 cases at some point in the initial month. Consequently, one should expect a choppy environment in the near term.

S&P 500 after the capitulation indicator fell below −4.25
The 14 signal dates since 1929 and the S&P 500's price return afterward, in %.
Return after the signal (%)
Signal dateOff high1 wk2 wk1 mo2 mo3 mo6 mo12 mo
1929-10-29−35.884.6−5.86.01.16.926.65.2
1946-03-06−8.071.32.25.27.98.43.6−10.0
1946-09-04−19.69−2.7−4.3−3.1−7.8−7.43.82.7
1953-09-15−14.11.32.64.65.98.917.138.5
1957-10-11−17.69−1.5−0.9−3.3−1.0−0.72.625.5
1962-05-29−20.040.5−4.4−6.3−0.41.27.021.1
1966-08-29−20.763.35.13.57.67.917.624.6
1987-10-20−29.68−1.55.93.75.22.48.118.0
1998-08-31−19.346.98.46.213.421.628.237.9
2008-01-08−11.18−0.7−3.7−3.8−8.4−2.6−10.5−34.8
2015-08-24−11.154.24.02.48.410.41.915.5
2018-12-19−14.46−0.71.05.010.711.717.727.9
2020-03-12−26.74−2.96.011.315.721.034.659.0
2025-04-07−17.61
Mean0.91.22.44.56.912.217.8
Median0.52.23.75.97.98.121.1
% positive54%62%69%69%77%92%85%
Avg max loss−1.9−4.3−4.9−5.4−5.4−5.7−10.0
Avg max gain5.15.56.98.811.416.525.3
Z-score0.90.71.31.62.12.41.5
Off high is the S&P 500's distance below its high on the signal date. Avg max loss and avg max gain are the average largest decline and largest gain within each window. A z-score of 2 or more means the result differs from random returns. Source: SentimenTrader, using S&P and CRSP data.

Over the bullish six-month window, a maximum loss of -10% was surpassed in only 2 out of 13 cases, albeit a few were close. By comparison, 9 of 13 rose more than 10%, underscoring a favorable risk-reward profile.  

Largest loss and largest gain after each capitulation signal
S&P 500 maximum loss and maximum gain within each window after the signal, in %.
Maximum loss (%)
Signal date1 wk2 wk1 mo2 mo3 mo6 mo12 mo
1929-10-290.0−13.6−13.6−13.6−13.6−13.6−13.6
1946-03-060.0−0.6−0.6−0.6−0.6−0.6−17.9
1946-09-04−5.6−5.6−7.3−8.7−8.7−8.7−11.3
1953-09-15−0.1−0.1−0.1−0.1−0.1−0.1−0.1
1957-10-11−1.5−4.8−4.8−4.8−4.8−4.8−4.8
1962-05-29−1.4−4.4−9.9−9.9−9.9−9.9−9.9
1966-08-290.00.00.0−1.8−1.8−1.8−1.8
1987-10-20−3.9−3.9−3.9−5.5−5.5−5.5−5.5
1998-08-310.00.00.00.00.00.00.0
2008-01-08−0.7−5.7−5.7−8.4−8.4−10.5−45.9
2015-08-24−1.4−1.4−1.4−1.4−1.4−3.4−3.4
2018-12-19−6.2−6.2−6.2−6.2−6.2−6.2−6.2
2020-03-12−3.8−9.8−9.8−9.8−9.8−9.8−9.8
2025-04-07
Mean−1.9−4.3−4.9−5.4−5.4−5.7−10.0
Median−1.4−4.4−4.8−5.5−5.5−5.5−6.2
Beyond 5%2567778
Beyond 10%0111124
Largest of all−6.2−13.6−13.6−13.6−13.6−13.6−45.9
Maximum gain (%)
Signal date1 wk2 wk1 mo2 mo3 mo6 mo12 mo
1929-10-2918.218.218.218.218.226.626.9
1946-03-061.92.25.29.99.912.012.0
1946-09-043.43.43.43.43.44.84.8
1953-09-151.32.64.67.79.117.138.5
1957-10-111.81.81.81.91.94.025.5
1962-05-292.72.72.72.72.97.021.4
1966-08-294.35.17.47.610.518.428.6
1987-10-209.19.19.19.110.214.718.0
1998-08-316.98.411.413.424.633.748.2
2008-01-082.22.22.22.22.22.62.6
2015-08-245.15.15.48.411.411.415.7
2018-12-190.01.06.511.113.917.827.9
2020-03-129.39.312.518.530.344.459.0
2025-04-07
Mean5.15.56.98.811.416.525.3
Median3.43.45.48.410.214.725.5
Beyond 5%568991011
Beyond 10%11347911
Largest of all18.218.218.218.530.344.459.0
Beyond 5% and beyond 10% count the 13 signals with a maximum loss worse than −5% or −10%, or a maximum gain above 5% or 10%. Largest of all is the single biggest loss or gain across the 13 signals. Source: SentimenTrader, using S&P and CRSP data.

A closer examination of some potential scenarios

In 2018 and 2020, the S&P 500 bottomed three and seven days later. However, it's important to note that the Fed reversed its monetary policy stance in late December 2018 and initiated a whatever-it-takes bazooka policy in 2020.

V-shaped bottoms are rare and typically result from aggressive monetary or fiscal intervention. This comparison may hold weight if you anticipate a policy shift from the Fed or the Trump administration.

The 2018 and 2020 capitulation signals
S&P 500 daily close and the capitulation indicator, Feb 2018 to Jan 2021. Signals on Dec 19, 2018 and Mar 12, 2020.
S&P 500 index level
2,0002,5003,0003,5004,000201920202021Dec 19, 2018Mar 12, 2020
2,0002,5003,0003,5004,000201920202021Dec 19, 2018Mar 12, 2020
Capitulation indicator
−6.00−4.00−2.000.002.00201920202021−4.25
−6.00−4.00−2.000.002.00201920202021−4.25
Source: SentimenTrader, using S&P and CRSP data; index levels from S&P Dow Jones Indices via Yahoo Finance.

The 2015 instance could provide a more likely roadmap for the current scenario should the economy avoid a recession. This example represented a significant growth scare correction.

The lack of clarity around tariffs may result in choppy price action within a wide range, testing investors' patience but rewarding tactical traders.

The 2015 capitulation signal
S&P 500 daily close and the capitulation indicator, Feb 2014 to Jan 2017. Signal on Aug 24, 2015.
S&P 500 index level
1,8001,9002,0002,1002,2002,300201520162017Aug 24, 2015
1,8002,0002,2002,400201520162017Aug 24, 2015
Capitulation indicator
−6.00−4.00−2.000.002.00201520162017−4.25
−6.00−4.00−2.000.002.00201520162017−4.25
Source: SentimenTrader, using S&P and CRSP data; index levels from S&P Dow Jones Indices via Yahoo Finance.

The 2008 precedent is a worst-case scenario, with the signal appearing early in the bear market. This comparison implies that the current tariff policy will push the economy into recession later this year.

The 2008 capitulation signal
S&P 500 daily close and the capitulation indicator, Aug 2006 to Jul 2009. Signal on Jan 8, 2008.
S&P 500 index level
6008001,0001,2001,4001,600200720082009Jan 8, 2008
5007501,0001,2501,5001,750200720082009Jan 8, 2008
Capitulation indicator
−6.00−4.00−2.000.002.00200720082009−4.25
−6.00−4.00−2.000.002.00200720082009−4.25
Source: SentimenTrader, using S&P and CRSP data; index levels from S&P Dow Jones Indices via Yahoo Finance.

What the research tells us...

By nearly any measure, the stock market is oversold, and sentiment is deeply pessimistic, conditions that often precede a rebound. Furthermore, Monday's price action may have marked what technicians call an "internal low," when the most significant pain is felt in individual stocks, even if stock indexes haven't yet reached their final bottom. While history suggests a rally, I suspect it's a bounce within the context of a downtrend, followed by a retest. What unfolds over the next 3, 6, or 12 months will depend heavily on how well the economy holds up under this significant shock. Traders should prioritize risk management with stop losses, whereas investors can use rallies to fine-tune their market exposure until there's more insight into the economic effects of tariffs.

Download this Insight as a PDF

Schedule a Call Today